Why do junctures become critical? Political discourse, agency, and joint belief shifts in comparative perspective

成果类型:
Article
署名作者:
Rinscheid, Adrian; Eberlein, Burkard; Emmenegger, Patrick; Schneider, Volker
署名单位:
University of St Gallen; York University - Canada; University of St Gallen; University of Konstanz
刊物名称:
REGULATION & GOVERNANCE
ISSN/ISSBN:
1748-5983
DOI:
10.1111/rego.12238
发表日期:
2020
页码:
653-673
关键词:
摘要:
Why do junctures become critical in some cases but not in others? Building on the critical juncture framework and perspectives on the formation and diffusion of beliefs, we develop a theoretically parsimonious and empirically traceable account of divergence in institutional outcomes. By illuminating the role of agency and joint belief shifts we further open the black box of critical junctures. In particular, we develop the argument that the role agents play is conditioned by conflict lines that structure an institutional field before a juncture sets in. Empirically, we trace political discourses around the 2011 Fukushima nuclear accident in Canada, Germany, and Japan using discourse network analysis. Through comparative investigation, we empirically show that discursive interactions during potential critical junctures indicate institutional outcomes that are shaped by causally relevant historical legacies.
来源URL: