Abu Ghraib, administrative evil, and moral inversion: The value of putting cruelty first

成果类型:
Article
署名作者:
Adams, Guy B.; Balfour, Danny L.; Reed, George E.
署名单位:
University of Missouri System; University of Missouri Columbia; Grand Valley State University
刊物名称:
PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION REVIEW
ISSN/ISSBN:
0033-3352
DOI:
10.1111/j.1540-6210.2006.00633.x
发表日期:
2006
页码:
680-693
关键词:
摘要:
The torture and abuse of detainees at Abu Ghraib prison and at other sites in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Cuba raise disturbing questions that have few, if any, easy answers. Were these intentionally evil acts committed by a few bad apples who took advantage of the power they wielded over the detainees? Or were they cases of administrative evil in which the obvious evil of torture and abuse was masked from the perpetrators, including those who performed subsidiary and supportive functions? The more fundamental question is, are torture and abuse always wrong? How close did the United States come to moral inversion in this case? Judith Shklar's concept of putting cruelty first aids our understanding of this case and points toward a trajectory that could help prevent future moral inversions and administrative evil.
来源URL: