What You Don't Know...Can't Hurt You? A Natural Field Experiment on Relative Performance Feedback in Higher Education

• 成果类型: Article
• 署名作者: Azmat, Ghazala; Bagues, Manuel; Cabrales, Antonio; Iriberri, Nagore
• 署名单位: Aalto University; University of London; University College London; Basque Foundation for Science; University of Basque Country
• 刊物名称: MANAGEMENT SCIENCE
• ISSN/ISSBN: 0025-1909
• DOI: 10.1287/mnsc.2018.3131
• 发表日期: 2019
• 页码: 3714-3736
• 关键词: relative performance feedback; ranking; Natural field experiment; School performance

摘要

This paper studies the effect of providing feedback to college students on their position in the grade distribution by using a natural field experiment. This information was updated every six months during a three-year period. We find that greater grades transparency decreases educational performance, as measured by the number of examinations passed and grade point average (GPA). However, self-reported satisfaction, as measured by surveys conducted after feedback is provided but before students take their examinations, increases. We provide a theoretical framework to understand these results, focusing on the role of prior beliefs and using out-of-trial surveys to test the model. In the absence of treatment, a majority of students underestimate their position in the grade distribution, suggesting that the updated information is good news for many students. Moreover, the negative effect on performance is driven by those students who underestimate their position in the absence of feedback. Students who overestimate initially their position, if anything, respond positively. The performance effects are short lived-by the time students graduate, they have similar accumulated GPA and graduation rates.